Immaculate and bright 5 bedroom 3 bathroom home steps from the ocean in Seaview. close to Ocean Beach. huge sunny deck, gardens, hot tub and yard. no ...






EXCLUSIVE – Fire Island home for sale in Seaview on a very special corner lot home with bay views. This unique A frame home boasts high ...





About Us

Deep Connection to the Fire Island Community

Wallace Real Estate is a family owned and operated business with over 50 years experience serving Fire Island. As respected members of the community who reside on Fire Island twelve months a year. Dana, Megan and Dylan are available to service all of your real estate needs at any time. We are ready to help your search for dream Fire Island homes for Rent or Sale today.


Let Us Get You Started - Discover the perfect Fire Island homes for sale or rent.

Discover Your Dream Home on Fire Island

There is no better time than now to get to know Fire Island, a beautiful and serene destination offering a unique blend of relaxation and adventure. Whether you’re looking for a summer getaway, a permanent residence, or an investment property, Fire Island has a diverse selection of homes to suit your needs. From charming beach cottages to luxurious waterfront estates, there is something for everyone. Fire Island’s real estate market thrives and evolves, providing numerous options for prospective buyers and renters. Additionally, the island is especially popular during the spring and summer rental season. Our expert team is ready to help you navigate the real estate process with ease, ensuring you find the perfect property to call your own.

Experience the Best of Island Living in New York

Fire Island stands out as the best of island living due to its unique charm, absence of cars, and close-knit community. Living on the Island offers pristine beaches, a vibrant community, and stunning natural beauty while residing in a home that offers comfort and style. With miles of unspoiled coastline, you can relax on the beach, explore the dunes, or enjoy water activities. The island’s vibrant social scene includes quaint shops, delightful restaurants, and a range of cultural events. The tranquil environment, combined with modern amenities, ensures you experience the perfect balance of serenity and convenience. Start your journey today and discover why so many people choose to buy or rent homes on Fire Island.

Explore Our Latest Listings

Thank you for visiting Explore our latest listings to find the ideal home that matches your lifestyle and budget, and make your dream of beach living a reality. Search now our Fire Island Homes for Sale or our Fire Island Homes for Rent.

Want Updates on the latest Rentals and Sales?
Sign up to join our mailing list!

Fair Housing Notice