Immerse yourself in an enchanting collage of coastal life and history. Rhythmic waves, high dunes, ancient maritime forests, historic landmarks and glimpses of wildlife, Fire Island has been a special place for diverse plants, animals and people for centuries. Far from the pressure of nearby big-city life, dynamic barrier island beaches offer both solitude and camaraderie, and spiritual renewal(NPS).
Are you looking for Fire Island real estate info? You’ve come to the right place. Our General Info page provides essential details about Fire Island, from transportation and local amenities to the island’s unique charm and community spirit. Whether you’re planning to buy, rent, or simply learn more about Fire Island, this page has everything you need.
First and foremost, Fire Island is renowned for its breathtaking beaches, vibrant communities, and tranquil environment. Our General Info page offers insights into the island’s history, wildlife, and recreational activities. Discover why Fire Island is a beloved destination for both residents and visitors, and explore the diverse attractions that make this island truly special.
Additionally, navigating life on Fire Island can be unique. Our page includes practical information about transportation, including ferry schedules and water taxi services, as well as details on local services and amenities. With our Fire Island real estate information, you’ll be well-prepared to make the most of your time on the island, whether you’re here for a short visit or considering a permanent move.
Thank you for visiting RealEstateOnFireIsland.com, your trusted source for Fire Island real estate information. Explore our page to learn more about this enchanting island and start your journey today. If you haven’t already – book a Fire Island Rental or look to purchase one of the available Fire Island homes for sale today.
Local carting and junk removal Dylan Wallace – 917-575-5251
Spoons – 631-583-7271
Peter Brenan – 631-583-9322
Sunshine Cleaning 631-767-4386
Natalia 631-882-8808
Pest Pro – 631-583-0300
Bike Repairs & Rentals- Beach Chairs- BBQ -Propane- Screens etc
Steve – 631-583-5826
Peter Brenan – 631-583-9322
Pond Road South Self Storage 631-218-4747 www.pondroadsouthselfstorage.com
Dylan Wallace 917-575-5251
1-800-verizon
On Move-In Day, we will try to be in the office but sometimes we are helping other tenants. There will be a Move-In Packet at the office. Please proceed to our office at 481 Bayberry. Click here for directions.
If you are fully paid, you will see a Move-In Packet hanging outside the office with your name and the name of the owner on it. If the house has a wagon, the combo will be in the Move-In Packet, as well as some other helpful information.
Also, please inquire about cleaning services as it is the tenant’s responsibility to have the house cleaned when vacated.
The house will be professionally cleaned before the move in day. The house should be left the same way when the tenant moves out. For cleaning services during your stay, stop into the office for some referrals.
If the cleaning crew is still on-site when you arrive, please be considerate and keep your luggage and belongs in one area so the crew can finish.
Please review the following trash rules and pick up times below. Please have trash in plastic bags inside closed trash containers outside the property for pick up. Please note that deer and wildlife are drawn to trash so please make sure it is tightly secured from curious creatures.
Trash pick up is Wednesday and Sunday evenings. Ocean Beach recycles newspapers, plastics and metals. Please have metals and plastics in a separate closed containers. The newspapers should be bundled together.
Trash pick up is Sunday and Thursday evenings. Corneille Estates recycles newspapers, plastics and metals. Please have metals and plastics in a separate closed containers. The newspapers should be bundled together.
Coming Soon! Seaview recycles newspapers, plastics and metals. Please have metals and plastics in a separate closed containers. The newspapers should be bundled together.
To have the power/ utilities/ phone put into the tenants name:
Make sure if you are the home owner, you have called L.I.P.A and or Verizon and given permission for your tenants to put the utilities into their names. This call should be made a few weeks before move in day, and is necessary for the utilities to be switched over.
Call L.I.P.A and or Verizon about a week before move in day. When you call, have the address or street name that you house is on as well as the last name of the owner, you have all this info on your lease, then, give them your billing information, and that’s it! This is a simple phone call the tenant must make about a week before move in day.
Fire Island’s maritime history precedes colonization of Long Island. Native Americans hunted and fished in the vicinity long before Colonial settlements were established. The economy and life patterns of residents have centered around the Great South Bay and Fire Island since the area was first settled.
The whaling industry, the era of the U. S. Life Saving Service, shipwrecks, habitation
📜 Fire Island History
Fire Island’s history stretches far beyond modern development—it is a story of natural resilience, survival, and vibrant coastal culture.
Long before colonization, Native American tribes, particularly the Secatogue people of the Algonquin Nation, hunted, fished, and traversed Fire Island and the surrounding bay. These early inhabitants relied on the barrier island for shellfish, waterfowl, and natural medicines found in its diverse ecosystems.
As European settlers arrived in the 1600s and 1700s, Fire Island became part of early maritime commerce. Whaling, baymen fishing, and trading shaped the economy and culture. By the 1800s, it had also become a critical route for seafaring vessels—many of which were met with the island’s treacherous sandbars and strong tides.
Due to the high number of shipwrecks off its coast, the U.S. Life-Saving Service—later merged into the U.S. Coast Guard—established stations along the island. Brave surfmen patrolled the beaches on foot, rescuing crews from doomed ships in brutal winter conditions. Remnants of these life-saving stations can still be seen and their legacy is preserved at the Fire Island Lighthouse museum.
In the late 19th and early 20th centuries, Fire Island began transforming into a haven for artists, writers, and vacationers. Small beach communities popped up—each with a distinct personality—many with bungalows that still stand today. During Prohibition, rumrunners used its secluded coves to smuggle alcohol from offshore boats onto the mainland.
Fire Island also played an important role in the LGBTQ+ movement, with Cherry Grove and Fire Island Pines emerging as pioneering communities in the mid-20th century, attracting performers, intellectuals, and activists who helped shape the cultural identity of the island and the nation.
The island has always been at the intersection of beauty and fragility. It has survived multiple hurricanes, including the infamous 1938 Long Island Express and Superstorm Sandy in 2012, which reshaped its landscape but not its spirit.
Today, Fire Island continues to be a sanctuary of heritage and nature—a protected landscape and cultural touchstone for generations past and future.
of the island, and the local fishing industry are some of the stories you may learn about at the Fire Island Lighthouse.
There is a long heritage of waterfowl hunting and shellfishing on the Great South Bay.
Seventeen communities had been developed on Fire Island before the establishment of the park. When Fire Island National Seashore was established in 1964, its enabling stated that these communities would be allowed to remain. The main communities to rent or buy each with its own charm, are Ocean Beach, Summer Club, Seaview, Ocean Bay Park, Corneille Estates, Robbins Rest and Atlantique.
Vacation and Rent
Ocean Beach, the heart of Fire Island, offers vibrant energy with nearly 600 homes, the island’s highest concentration of bars, restaurants, and shops. Visitors enjoy bustling streets lined with boutiques and ice cream shops, legendary nightlife, sandy beaches, and community events like the Sandpiper Run and annual Art Show.
Move and Live
Ocean Beach blends small-town charm with beach excitement. A close-knit, car-free community provides amenities like parks, playgrounds, and recreational facilities. Family-friendly programs and quiet residential areas make it ideal for long-term living.
Vacation and Rent
Seaview offers a tranquil escape with serene beaches, well-maintained homes, and beautiful gardens. Families enjoy uncrowded beaches, a community market, tennis courts, and playgrounds in a peaceful setting.
Move and Live
Year-round residents benefit from lush greenery, a strong sense of community, and easy access to local amenities. Seaview is ideal for families and retirees seeking a high-quality, relaxed lifestyle.
Vacation and Rent
Known for its lively atmosphere, Ocean Bay Park is perfect for younger crowds. The area features casual eateries, beach bars, bustling beaches with volleyball and surfing, and vibrant nightlife.
Move and Live
Ocean Bay Park offers a social, casual lifestyle in a diverse, welcoming community. Residents enjoy outdoor activities, natural beauty, and ample opportunities for socializing.
Vacation and Rent
Corneille Estates offers an exclusive, serene vacation experience with private beaches and upscale homes. It’s perfect for those seeking peace and relaxation.
Move and Live
Residents enjoy a high-quality, private living environment with well-maintained properties in a close-knit, tranquil community ideal for families and individuals.
Vacation and Rent
Summer Club provides exclusivity with luxurious amenities and private beaches. It’s perfect for those seeking privacy and a high-end vacation experience.
Move and Live
Living in Summer Club means access to private amenities like tennis courts and a clubhouse in a secure, supportive, and tight-knit community.
Vacation and Rent
Robbins Rest offers a peaceful, family-friendly escape with uncrowded beaches, hiking, and bird watching. It’s ideal for connecting with nature.
Move and Live
Residents enjoy a tranquil, welcoming community perfect for families and those seeking a slower pace of life. The small, close-knit neighborhood ensures a safe and supportive environment.
🏖 The Beaches
Fire Island’s beaches are legendary — clean, uncrowded, and perfect for relaxing, playing, or soaking up the sun. Visit white sand stretches in Ocean Beach, Seaview, and Ocean Bay Park. Boogie boarding, swimming, and beachcombing are popular, and we provide up-to-date surf and swell info on our site.
🚲 Biking the Island
Biking is one of the best ways to explore the island’s charming neighborhoods and nature trails. Fat-tire bikes are recommended for sandy areas. Rentals are available throughout the island, but check ferry rules if you plan to bring your own.
🌅 Sunsets on the Bay
Don’t miss the spectacular sunsets over the Great South Bay. Top viewing spots include the Ocean Beach ferry dock and the Seaview marina. Bring a drink and enjoy the show.
🥂 Dining & Drinks
From casual to upscale, Fire Island offers diverse dining and nightlife. Ocean Beach has cafes, restaurants, pizza, and cocktails. Ocean Bay Park is known for its fun beach bars and bayfront meals. Sunset dinners are a must.
🚶 Nature Walks & Trails
Explore the natural beauty of Fire Island. Visit the Sunken Forest at Sailors Haven, hike the Otis Pike Wilderness near Watch Hill, or climb the historic Fire Island Lighthouse for 360° views.
🛍 Boutique Shopping
Find beachwear, local art, gifts, and handmade items in the island’s villages. Ocean Beach and Cherry Grove offer the best shopping variety.
⚓ Boating & Kayaking
Enjoy the bay from the water. Kayaks, paddleboards, and small boat rentals are available in Ocean Beach, Atlantique, and Seaview. It’s a great way to explore and unwind.
🐚 Family Fun
Fire Island is perfect for families. Enjoy playgrounds, bay swimming, shell collecting, and crabbing. Youth programs and kid-friendly events are offered in summer.
🎨 Art, Music & Events
Enjoy live music, art shows, and local events all season long. Catch an outdoor movie night, visit a community art fair, or join seasonal traditions like the Sandpiper Run.
🌊 Wellness & Relaxation
Relax with beach yoga, massage therapy, or a quiet sunrise walk. Services are available in Ocean Beach and Cherry Grove, and the island’s natural beauty offers peaceful moments everywhere.
🍽 Where to Eat on Fire Island
Explore diverse dining experiences, from casual beachfront eateries to refined waterfront restaurants.
Ocean Beach
Albatross – 320 Bay Walk · 631‑583‑5697
CJ’s Restaurant & Bar – 479 Bay Ave. · 631‑583‑9890
Maguire’s Bayfront Restaurant – 1 Bungalow Ln. · 631‑583‑8800
Rachel’s Bakery & Restaurant – 325 Bay Walk · 631‑583‑9552
Bocce Beach Restaurant & Bar
Cast Away Bar & Grill
The Hideaway
Houser’s Hotel & Restaurant
Ice Castle Ice Cream
Island Mermaid · Matthew’s Seafood House · Michael’s Ristorante & Pizzeria · Sandbar Fire Island · Surfs Out Restaurant & Bar
Ocean Bay Park
Flynn’s Fire Island – 1 Cayuga St. · 631‑583‑5000
The Pines
Blue Whale – Harbor Walk · 631‑597‑6500
Pines Bistro & Martini Bar – 36 Fire Island Blvd. · 631‑597‑6862
Top of the Bay Bistro – 159 Dock Walk · 631‑597‑6028
Cherry Grove
Cherry Grove Pizza
Cherry’s on the Bay · 631‑597‑7859
Floyd’s – 156 Bayview Walk
Jumpin’ Jack’s Seafood Shack
Sand Castle – 106 Lewis Walk · 631‑597‑4174
Fair Harbor
Le Dock – 62 Bay Walk · 631‑583‑5200
Davis Park
Casino Café – Oceanfront dining with bar and live music
Kismet
Dive Kismet – Marina dining
Kismet Inn
Fire Island Tap – Bar & Grill
Dunewood / Watch Hill
The Pier Restaurant & Tiki Bar (Watch Hill Marina)
Atlantique
The Shack Atlantique – Casual bayfront fare & drinks
Note: Most restaurants operate seasonally (May–Labor Day) and offer scenic waterfront views, live music, and seasonal specials. Reservations are recommended for dinner.
🌟 Places to Go on Fire Island
Discover iconic landmarks, hidden natural treasures, and unforgettable experiences across the island.
Fire Island Lighthouse
Visible from the ferry, this is the tallest lighthouse on Long Island. Climb to the top to see the NYC skyline and explore maritime exhibits, the historic Fresnel Lens, boardwalks, boathouse, and beach. Seasonal art shows, workshops, and ranger programs keep each visit unique.
William Floyd Estate
Visit the ancestral home of a Declaration of Independence signer. Tour 250 years of family history, original furnishings, and the evolving landscape across centuries. Beautiful interiors and gardens tell the story of early American life.
Sunken Forest (Sailors Haven)
This globally rare maritime holly forest is hidden behind the dunes. Visit from May to October via Sayville ferry. Walk the raised boardwalks and experience unique ecology—restrooms and ferry services are seasonal.
Watch Hill (Otis Pike Wilderness)
Explore Fire Island’s largest salt marsh, dunes, and wilderness. Accessible by ferry, boat, or on foot, Watch Hill offers a visitor center, campground, marina, snack bar, lifeguarded beach, guided nature programs, and self-guided trails (May–mid‑October).
Sunrise/Sunset Viewing Spots
Watch unforgettable sunrises over the ocean and sunsets across the bay. Top vantage points include the lighthouse grounds, ocean-facing beaches, and ferry docks at Seaview and Ocean Beach.
Barrett’s Beach & Joan’s Gallery
In Cherry Grove, stroll along Barrett’s Beach and pop into Joan’s Gallery for local art exhibitions and quirky finds—especially lively during community events.
Cherry Grove & The Pines Villages
Explore these iconic LGBTQ+ friendly communities known for their vibrant social scenes, waterfront walkways, and rich summer entertainment including concerts and drag shows.
Fishing Piers & Bay Access Points
Bring your rod to public docks in Seaview, Ocean Bay Park, and Cherry Grove for bay fishing, crab-catching, and peaceful water-side lounging.
Guided Nature & History Walks
Join National Park Service-led programs at Sailors Haven or Watch Hill: birdwatching, marsh tours, dune ecology, and lighthouse history deepen your understanding of Fire Island’s unique environment.
Kismet Marina & Bayfront:
Browse the marina docks, enjoy bayfront dining at Dive Kismet and The Shack, and take in a more relaxed pace of island life in this friendly community.
